I don’t generally like peak lapels on
single-breasted suits. They aren’t necessarily wrong – although notch lapels
are far more common, only the relatively inexperienced will tell you it is a
‘rule’ that SBs must have notch lapels (or indeed black tie have peak lapels). Have
a look back through some 1930s stills or films and you will find plenty of
evidence to the contrary.
But peak lapels, for me, often look short
and stubby on a single-breasted jacket. More like little bat wings than long,
elegant fins. On a double-breasted, the crossover allows the lapel a crucial
few inches more, echoing the smart military style of a sash or cross-belt.
The image of Gary Cooper above I think
illustrates the point. Part of the problem is that these old suits had a higher
buttoning point – where the waist button, the top of a two-button suit,
fastens. They were cut with that point on the natural waist, just below the
ribs, where the trousers also sat. That leaves less room for lapel.
The only way to save a peak-lapel SB
design, then, is to lower that buttoning point as much as possible. They tend
to be a good couple of inches lower on high-street suits today, but bespoke
tailors will often retain a high waist button, even if the trousers are cut
rather lower. The proportions of the jacket, after all, are still mostly derived
from the same system of cutting that was developed for the hunting coat, which
buttoned high and cut away sharply to allow it to be worn closed while mounted.
High-street retailers still retain a high buttoning
point sometimes, as shown in the Reiss suit opposite. But below, you can see
the difference of just an inch or so, in an Armani suit being worn by Kobe
Bryant. And it’s no coincidence that peak lapels were often cut for more
formal, three-piece suits like the grey Bryant wears. As these may have been
worn open more often, the lapel has rather more freedom.
Finally Gianluca Bocache, of the shop Sartoria Ripense in Rome, shows how the buttoning point can work well in a custom-made suit. I repeat that I don’t like peak lapels and I still think this would look better as a notch, but if you’re going to do it, then give the lapel a little more length.
Bryant images: GQ. Bocache image: The Sartorialist












I disagree. What really matters is the width of the lapel. If peaked lapels are narrow, they won't look stubby even with a high button. On the other hand, if the peaked lapels are wide, they will look strange with either high or low buttons. With high buttons, they will look short and stubby. With low buttons, they will look loose and flappy.
ReplyDeleteThe natural width of a lapel is the width it would be if it actually buttoned all the way up to the neck, instead of folding over. In the 30s, when lapels looked short and stubby, they were significantly wider than that. To look sleek and pointed, a peak lapel needs to be cut a little narrower than natural width. To look full and luxurious, as if showing off that the wearer has cloth and style to spare, they can be cut wider (something that's hard to do with a notch lapel). Hence, the 30s look.
That's certainly a factor Matthew, but for me even a narrow short lapel looks unbalanced
DeleteI think that they look better with wide lapels. Look at the Edward Sexton suits. I think they look fantastic.
Delete/Anders
I don't like them in general - they look too comical on a single breasted suit.
ReplyDeleteI had a lovely one button, single breasted, peak lapel jacket made by John Kent for my wedding. When done well (like mine, but I'm biased!), I think it looks great.
ReplyDeleteI was going to mention actually, Chris, that my linen suit from John has a good low buttoning point. Notch lapel, but could have worked with peak possibly. Post on that on Friday
DeleteSimon
SC-- Could not agree with you more!!! Your first sentence sums it up.
ReplyDeleteIf one thinks about the origins of a jacket buttoned at the collar, SB with a peak lapel makes no sense. You have only to visualize the line of lapels closed and buttoned to see what an awkward line it would create. --John
Hello Simon,
ReplyDeleteJust FYI, Ripense and Gian Luca parted their ways. Gian Luca has opened a new store on his own (Bocache Salvucci) that is totally independant from Ripense. The latter has developed a new partnership with another shoemaker.
And to relate more to the topic, I do like single breasted peak lapel jackets as they offer another style, very chic, albeit less formal
Interesting, thanks Paul. I haven't been in a while
DeleteSimon,
ReplyDeleteInteresting post and spot-on, in my opinion. I have an RLPL 3-piece (my favorite suit), but it only works (in my opinion) because of the lower button stance that allows more room for the lapels to "develop".
On the other hand, I still appreciate the beauty of the lines in the 1930s version which is lovely to look at when done right, bat-wings and all. I did a post last year highlighting George Raft's 3-piece SB with peaked lapels in Night After Night. Some of the touches are dated, but it still exudes a certain elegance (the high-waisted trousers, high button placement, high arm-hole positions, etc.)
http://uptowndandy.blogspot.com/2011/05/george-raft-americas-lost-sartorial.html
Dan F.
Hi Simon, I would like to add a small point to your anaysis above. I agree with you that peak lapels on single-breasted jackets are perfectly legitimate and very nice in theory, but the result is very often less flattering than expected, and you have already listed the reasons for that. One additional thing that I have noted, should one want to go for the peak lapels, is that on a single-breasted jacket they tend to work better with an Italian-style, rolled-lapel cut, where the movement of the rolled lapel helps giving a bit more plasticity to the lapel itself, all the way up to its peak. There is a memorable illustration of this on Alan Flusser's "Dressing the Man" book, in a grey plaid suit worn by Douglas Fairbanks Jr.:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.2dosesaday.com/post/12869202593/douglas-fairbanks-jr-gary-cooper-from-alan
Alex
What about peaked lapels on single-breasted dinner jackets--the black tie standard?
ReplyDeleteOf course, nothing wrong with that. Again, just make sure the lapel is long enough. It helps that you will have a waistcoat underneath and therefore it also looks good if the jacket is open
Delete