Wednesday, 12 December 2012

The tailors I have known: Part 1, London



Following a recent request from a reader, here is a breakdown of all the English tailors I have tried. I include a description of the style and then one of my experiences. All the links are to pictures or more details elsewhere on the blog. If you have any questions or want me to compare particular tailors, perhaps on a specific aspect of their work, please comment below the post.

I'll do a post on Italy, France and Hong Kong on Friday.

Anderson & Sheppard

The biggest exponent of the 'drape cut', with soft shoulders and fullness of cloth in the chest and back. Together with a closely cut waist, it gives the illusion of a bigger chest and is very comfortable. Some think that the soft shoulders are unflattering.

It is among the cheaper houses on the Row, and I particularly like the double-breasted style as it has a relatively broad lapel with plenty of belly. Most of my suits are from A&S, cut by John Hitchcock.

Huntsman

The opposite of Anderson & Sheppard in style, with strong, padded shoulders and a closely cut chest. Relatively slim through the waist and with little skirt, it is known for a one-button fastening. Most other English tailors cut this traditional style, with slight variations.

I liked the hunting suit I had made by David Ward. We had some problems with the bi-swing back, as the vents stayed open and elastic was added inside to fix that.

Henry Poole

The other one of the big three names on the Row, it is more flexible in house style than either A&S or Huntsman. The basic cut is strong and English, however, with slightly less padding and structure in the shoulder and chest than Huntsman.

I had a double-breasted Prince of Wales suit made, which has been quietly superb. It gets more compliments that almost anything else, yet it is conservative in everything by the cloth. Cut by Craig Featherstone.

Richard Anderson

Richard used to be the head cutter at Huntsman and his cut is similar, though with less padding in the shoulder. One difference is perhaps a more adventurous style; he has recently been making some for customers in wool jersey, for example.

Richard made me a tuxedo, single breasted with a shawl-collared waistcoat. It was slim and perfectly fitting, though my favourite part was the superb trousers.

Steven Hitchcock

Son of A&S head cutter John Hitchcock, Steven was trained there and his style is very similar. As he works in shared premises on the Row, he is of course cheaper.

Steven made me a tweed jacket and moleskin trousers. If anything I found his style to be softer and drapier than his father.

John Kent and Terry Haste

John and Terry work with Stephen Lachter (shirt cutter) on Sackville Street. Terry was head cutter at Huntsman and his style is very similar; John tends to cut a slightly smaller back and slimmer leg - sharper, in that way.

John made my pattern and I have two suits from it, the second cut and fitted by Terry - hence the difference in styles noted above. The make was superb and I would say they are the best value on the Row.

Gieves & Hawkes

Gieves style is, like Poole and others, a traditional English military cut. They are often ignored in discussions of Row tailors but have a large tailoring department and a strong foreign and military client list.

My travel blazer and trousers were cut by Kathryn Sargent, who has now set up on her own and shares premises on Sackville Street. They were both very well done. Davide Taub, of whose style I am a big fan, is now cutting at Gieves instead.

Timothy Everest

Tim is a wonderful stylist and designer. His cutter in the Elder Street bespoke operation in east London is Lloyd Forester. Lloyd's style is traditionally English though with less structure; Tim adds a dash of innovation to the mix during the commissioning and fittings.

The suit and velvet jacket I had made were both well done. The strength is in Tim's consultation, and the rack of unusual things that are guaranteed to be hanging around.

Graham Browne

A traditional English cut but with willingness to experiment. Currently making some of the best non-Italian soft jackets I've seen in terms of cut.

Although not the same standard of make as Savile Row, Graham Browne is by far the best value tailoring in London. I have had many things made over the years, I have all my alterations done there, and my first bespoke suit in London, which was made by them, is still one of my favourites.

Choppin & Lodge is the travelling side of Graham Browne.

Thom Sweeney

A much more contemporary cut than anyone else on this list - a short jacket, narrow sleeve and fitted waist. Famous for their horseshoe waistcoats.

Thom Whiddett and Luke Sweeney are great stylists, with Thom the cutter. Their strength is style, youth and innovation. Checked jacket and cord trousers here.

Hemingway Tailors

Run by Toby Luper, who is based in Leeds but visits clients in London, and has the suits made at Cheshire Bespoke. The style is English but with a particularly large and extended shoulder.

Toby is not a cutter, and normally I would avoid being fitted by anyone who is not a cutter. But the trousers Toby cut me are probably the best fitting I have.

35 comments:

  1. Hi there

    I notice Kilgour by it's absence - they never seem to get mentioned in discussions (much like Gieves). Is there any particular reason for this?

    Regards

    Kieron

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They've gone through a lot of changes, with cutters leaving (most recently to Hayward). I know them and like the style (generally like Huntsman but with a bit more flair to the skirt), but I've never had anything made there so can't really recommend them.

      Delete
  2. simon you say huntsman have 'little skirt' .. this is not true at all?! the skirt is slightly longer than a normal saville row jacket and flairs more agressively .. how can this be little skirt?

    Andy

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The jacket is certainly longer, but in my experience it doesn't flair as much as other English houses. That may of course vary with the cutter.

      Delete
  3. Simon
    Good to have an overview of your experiences in London. I am just wondering, purely out of interest, why Kilgour is omitted? From reading the London Cut they seem to be one of the big founding members of the row, Cary Grant, Fred Astaire etc. hence my curiosity.
    Many thanks.
    Best
    James

    ReplyDelete
  4. Seems you should visit Chittleborough & Morgan and discuss their take on Tommy Nutters cut.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know Joe and Roy very well. They've done some work adding Milanese buttonholes to some of my suits. But I have yet to have anything made.

      Delete
  5. Simon, very interesting post. Just one question about Graham Browne: I have had a number of suits made by them and I noticed one thing: On the back the lapel it seems as if the canvas is "glued" to the cloth (on the front this is not the case). Do you know if that is normal for bespoke, or does that mean that the lapels are partly fused?

    Many thanks,
    S

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. None of their suits are fused at all, so it can't be glue. They do sew them by machine there sometimes (as others, including Poole, do), but it certainly won't be glue.

      Best to go in and ask them, or send me a picture.

      Delete
    2. I think you are right. After closer examination it does seem that they are sown very tightly, in rows of stitches on the back of the lapel. Is that how one usually does it?

      S

      Delete
  6. To avoid the impression of being unethical it might not be a bad idea to have a space on your blog where you list your conflicts of interest, i.e., getting free or discounted goods, whom you work for etc. Case in point: Anderson & Sheppard is list first here. Why? Because you work for them. Just a coinicidence ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There is a disclosure on the right side of the blog, though I admit a long way down now as the advertising has increased.

      I am approached every single day for sponsored posts, sponsored links, reader competitions etc, but have deliberately kept it to just display advertising as I think this is the most transparent.

      I mention the work with A&S frequently but people have commented that it's hardly needed. Any regular reader would be aware of it.

      Delete
  7. By the way, Guy has a great comparison of the suits he has had made, at several of these places, here:

    http://www.dashingtweeds.co.uk/company-info/gallery-and-tailors/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Simon,

    Do you have any experience of Mark Marengo? I've heard good things but have not yet met anyone who has had something made by him. A few I know seem to think the Mark Stephen OTR line is ok.

    Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, I don't. He doesn't do bespoke I don't think?

      Delete
  9. This is very good stuff — not only interesting but also very useful. Do you also have similar information on tailors who will make trousers without coats?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not sure I understand. Everyone here will make trousers without coats.

      Delete
  10. I don't think I've ever seen the Richard Anderson suit you had made. Would you ever consider posting photos of it?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've only just got it and did a photo shoot with it for The Rake last week. I'll certainly post photos of it soon

      Delete
  11. Which tailors have you used to make just slacks without a coat, and what were their strengths and weaknesses?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Graham Browne is the only one that has made just trousers for me. They were good, solid, like everything at GB.

      Others have made odd trousers with a jacket - Thom Sweeney, Steven Hitchcock, Anderson & Sheppard. Of those I think Steven's were probably the best

      Simon

      Delete
  12. Hi.

    A very long time ago on your blog you had posts about A Suit That Fits, but you do not include them (favourably or unfavourably) in this list. Is that oversight or deliberate omission?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have deliberately only included bespoke firms in this list. I have had made to measure from ASTF, Henry Herbert and others, but couldn't really recommend them.

      Delete
  13. Thanks for clarifying.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I may be starting a new job having been out of office work for some time. Many of my suits are (well) past their best (apart from 1 from Graham Browne). I will likely commission a couple from the list above, but that will take time and I might need at least one new suit quickly, should the job pan out.

    Is there anywhere that you would suggest in London for "modified" OTR or rapid MTM?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, sorry I don't have much experience of MTM but always set aside 10% of any OTR purchase to have it alteres

      Delete
  15. Hi,

    I would be interested to know what about Graham Browne is not Savile Row quality? Could I also ask whether you have any knowledge or expereince of Cad & The Dandy. I understand that they do a fully bespoke service.

    I am hoping to have a suit made in the next few weeks and have narrowed my choice of tailor down to the teo aforementioned. I would be interested in your views.

    Many thanks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's mostly small things like elements of machine padding in the chest (which other expensive makes, such as Kiton, also do) and thicker buttonholes. The latter has improved in recent years though.

      The Cad & The Dandy do do a full bespoke but they are not tailors. I would go with Graham Browne

      Delete
  16. Do you have any experience with Chris Kerr ?

    ReplyDelete
  17. Who is making your next item ? Do you only buy bespoke now ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes - and fewer clothes overall as a result, which is good.

      I'm waiting on jackets from Solito and Liverano

      Delete
  18. May I ask if you have any plan to commission a suit at Dege and Skinner? That house also seems interesting, and I guess the structure is quite similar to that of Huntsman...?

    ReplyDelete
  19. I have no plans to, largely because the style isn't that different to others

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...